Call Contact
Menu
Fees & costs

How to Compare Property Management Fees in Japan: Revenue Basis, Costs and Contracts

Illustration of a balance scale and coins

When you compare management companies for a hotel, ryokan, holiday home or vacation rental, the first thing you notice is probably the fee rate: "X% of revenue." But two rates that look the same are not always the same underneath. What counts as "revenue"? Which tasks does the fee cover? What additional costs come on top? The answers affect both what remains for you as the owner and how much you can hand over. In this article, we set out the points to check before you get a quote or sign a contract, so you can compare management fees fairly.

Why comparing fee rates alone can be misleading

In most cases, management pricing is a combination of three things: the fee rate, additional costs and contract terms. The rate is only one part of it.

For example, a rate may look low, while arranging cleaning or on-site support is charged separately. The "revenue" the fee is based on may also be defined broadly. On the other hand, a rate may look high but include everything from marketing to cleaning management and reports. In that case, there are fewer tasks and costs for you to arrange yourself.

That's why it helps to line up the following three points for each company before you decide:

  • How "revenue" is defined for calculating the fee
  • What costs are charged in addition to the fee, and who pays them
  • Which tasks the fee covers, and which tasks you will still handle as the owner

If you put rates side by side without lining up these three points, you end up comparing numbers based on different conditions.

Check how "revenue" is defined

Even when it says "X% of revenue," what "revenue" means can differ from company to company and contract to contract. Check the following points in the quote or contract:

  • Is accommodation revenue counted including or excluding consumption tax?
  • Is it the amount before or after deducting the commissions paid to booking sites (OTAs)?
  • If you charge guests a cleaning fee, is that cleaning fee included in the fee calculation?
  • How are accommodation tax and other taxes, extra-guest charges and optional sales handled?
  • If you receive cancellation fees, are they included in the calculation?
  • Is revenue from direct bookings (your own website, phone, etc.) calculated on the same terms?

It also helps to check whether the fee rate itself includes tax, so your comparison stays consistent. Don't go by the impression the wording gives. Make sure the calculation method is clearly written in the contract or quote.

Checklist of costs charged in addition to the fee

Running and maintaining a property involves actual costs on top of the management fee. Go through them item by item: which costs are included in the fee, and which ones do you pay as the owner? Beyond the amounts, you'll have more peace of mind if you also ask who arranges each item, who pays for it and how it is reported.

  • Cleaning fees (how the price per cleaning is set and what tasks cleaning includes)
  • Linen (sheets, towels, etc.) rental and laundry costs
  • How consumables (amenities, detergent, toilet paper, etc.) are purchased and restocked, and what they cost
  • Utilities and communication costs (internet connection, etc.)
  • OTA commissions
  • Payment processing fees (credit cards, etc.)
  • Repair and equipment replacement costs, and the approval process before anything is ordered
  • Costs and conditions for emergency response (night call-outs, key or equipment problems, etc.)
  • Photography costs (such as shoots by a professional photographer)
  • Fees for tools such as a channel manager (a system that manages bookings and availability across multiple booking sites in one place) and smart locks
  • Whether there is an initial fee (the cost of preparing to start operations), and what it covers

Costs vary with the size of the property, its facilities and occupancy. Check not only the monthly costs but also the preparation costs at the start of operations. That way, you are less likely to face unexpected expenses later.

Check the scope of services and who does what

Even under the same label of "property management," the scope of services differs by company and plan. Don't decide based on names like "all-inclusive" or "full support" alone. Check who is responsible for each task.

  • Marketing and reservation management: which booking sites the property is listed on, and who creates and updates the listings
  • Rate adjustments: who reviews room rates, and how often. Not just whether there is a tool, but whether there is a person making the decisions
  • Guest communication: which languages (English, Chinese, Korean, etc.) and what hours
  • Cleaning: who arranges the cleaning company, how the result is checked after cleaning, and what happens if something is missed
  • On-site support: the hours, areas and costs for going to the property
  • Guest reviews: who replies to reviews and who works on the issues raised
  • Reports: what is reported, how often and in what format

One thing that is easy to overlook: the hours for guest messaging and the hours for on-site call-outs are separate. If you see "24-hour support," check whether that means messaging only or includes on-site support too. If you live overseas, it's also worth checking which language is used to communicate with you and how contact works across time zones.

Check the contract terms and what happens on cancellation

Even if you are happy with the fee and the scope of services, some contract terms can make it hard to change course later if you want to rethink how your property is run. Before signing, check the following:

  • The contract term, and whether it renews automatically
  • The notice deadline for cancellation (how many months in advance you need to tell them)
  • Any costs on cancellation, and how the final settlement works
  • Whether fees still apply after the contract ends to future bookings made before it ended
  • Whose name the booking site accounts are in, and whether you or the management company holds admin rights
  • Whether you can keep using the listing photos and descriptions after the contract ends
  • Whether reviews and listing pages can be carried over (this depends on each booking site's terms)
  • Whether there is an initial fee, and what work it covers

How accounts and reviews are handled can have a big impact when you switch management companies. If you are considering a switch, you can find specific points to check in Choosing and switching management companies.

Questions to ask when comparing

Ask every company the same questions before you get quotes. This makes it easier to compare them on equal terms.

  1. What amount is the fee calculated on? Including or excluding tax? Before or after OTA commissions?
  2. Is the cleaning fee collected from guests included in the fee calculation?
  3. Which tasks are included in the fee, and which are not?
  4. What costs are charged in addition to the fee? How are costs approved and reported?
  5. For guest messaging and for on-site support, what hours do you cover, and in which areas?
  6. How do you check the quality of cleaning? What do you do if something is missed?
  7. Do your monthly reports show not only revenue but also a breakdown of costs and any operational issues?
  8. What are the contract term, the notice deadline for cancellation and the costs on cancellation?
  9. When the contract ends, what happens to bookings, settlements, account admin rights and reviews?

Don't settle for verbal answers. Get them in writing as well, such as in a quote or contract. If each company works on different assumptions, list the differences side by side before you decide. That makes the comparison easier.

How we at Alotz approach pricing

We at Alotz offer two plans, depending on which tasks you want to entrust to us. All prices shown include tax.

  • Guest Messaging Plan: 10% of revenue (tax included). We handle multilingual guest support in English, Chinese, Korean and more, guest messaging 24 hours a day, 365 days a year, and collecting guest information before arrival.
  • Full Management Plan: 20% of revenue (tax included). We handle marketing and reservation management via booking sites, rate adjustments with dynamic pricing (a system that adjusts room rates to match demand), guest messaging, arranging and managing cleaning, responding to guest reviews, and monthly financial reports.

For both plans, the fee is calculated on "accommodation sales including consumption tax, minus OTA and other booking-site commissions." Actual costs such as cleaning, utilities and consumables are paid separately. If on-site emergency response is needed, additional costs apply depending on the work required. Please note that "24 hours a day, 365 days a year" refers to guest messaging. On-site call-outs and our hours for owners need to be confirmed separately.

We are also currently running a campaign with no initial fee (¥0). The initial fee we normally charge (covering initial consulting, creating a house guide, travel expenses, writing OTA descriptions, listing on each OTA, and channel manager setup) becomes ¥0. Interior design consulting, professional photography fees and similar costs are not included in the campaign. We will explain eligibility when you consult us. For details, see our Pricing page.

If you already use another management company or run your property yourself, we also offer a free second opinion. We review your current operation together with you and point out what can be improved. There is no obligation to switch or sign a contract. For details, see Revenue improvement & second opinion.

Summary

You can't compare management fees by the rate alone. Look at the definition of "revenue" the fee is based on, the costs charged on top of the fee, the scope of services and division of roles, and the contract term and cancellation terms. Comparing these on equal terms makes it easier to choose a management company that suits your property.

  • Check whether "revenue" includes tax, and how OTA commissions and cleaning fees are treated
  • For each additional cost, check who arranges it, who pays it and how it is reported
  • Check the hours for messaging and the hours for on-site support separately
  • Before signing, check the cancellation terms and how bookings, accounts and reviews are handled
  • Get answers in writing, and sort out the differences in each company's assumptions

We at Alotz first listen to your property's situation and which tasks you want to entrust, then explain the management fee, additional costs and the preparation needed before launch. Even if you're still comparing, whatever information you have is fine to start with. Feel free to contact us through our contact form.

Related articles

Back to all articles